January 17, 2012
Was “The Lion King” story based on the Mali legend of Sundiata?

“I expect better from the Daily Planet,” says an upset commenter on my review of the stage adaptation of Disney’s The Lion King. “The Lion King story was stolen from the Mali people. It’s loosely based on its founder Sundiata Keita. This account is a well-known oral tradition. And all these European influences/renditions is nothing but an attempt to capitalize on it without giving the people its proper credit.”

As evidence to support this claim, the anonymous commenter cites a 1994 paper presented at an annnual meeting of the National Council of Teachers of English. Though the paper describes parallels between The Lion King and the epic of Sundiata—a traditional tale of Mali—the paper presents no evidence that the filmmakers, who have acknowledged debts to Shakespeare’s Hamlet and the Biblical tales of Joseph and Moses, were familiar with the story. I responded to the commenter:

“Stories of jealousy and conflict over royal succession are common across a number of cultures, and while I defer to more knowledgable sources as to whether The Lion King is a fitting tribute to or a reductive distortion of African cultural traditions, I don’t see evidence to support your claim that the story was ‘stolen from the Mali people.’”

The commenter responded defensively, citing the authority of the paper’s academic source—which is irrelevant, since I was never questioning the paper’s accuracy. “Maybe they’re not using the words stolen,” says the commenter, “but the historical story of Sundiata is never given its proper credit.”

“Again,” I responded, “where is the evidence that the filmmakers knew the story of Sundiata? For them to have stolen the story, they would have to have known it in the first place.”

At this point I went off to do my own research on the Internet, and found several blog posts and study guides repeating the claim that “the Disney movie, The Lion King was based in part on the legend of Sundiata.” That quote comes from a Kennedy Center study guide, but like the other posts, it cites no evidence to support the claim. I also found several references to the paper cited by the Daily Planet commenter, describing the paper—accurately—as one that notes parallels, not one that provides evidence that the Disney team were familiar with the Mali legend.

It may well be that they were, and that they felt no more need to credit the African legend than they did to credit Shakespeare or the Bible. But now you’ve piqued my curiousity, Internet, and I’d like to get the story straight. Can anyone cite proof, beyond the circumstantial evidence I’ve seen thus far, that the makers of The Lion King were familiar with the legend of Sundiata?

- Jay Gabler

9:39am  |   URL: http://tmblr.co/ZqCSNyEwCoxa
  
Filed under: The Lion King 
January 14, 2012
“The Lion King” is still a stunner at 15

On stage, The Lion King feels like a vibrant celebration of African life—but once you start tracing its cultural pedigree, your mind reels. The story was cribbed from Shakespeare by Iowa-born sci-fi guru Thomas Disch, then set to music by flamboyant Brit Elton John with lyrics by Andrew Lloyd Webber’s main man Tim Rice. The film was produced by the American mythmakers at Disney, subsequently being adapted for the stage under the direction of Julie Taymor, a well-traveled Massachusetts native. Wait, what continent are we on?

However this team managed to pull it off—South African composer Lebo M collaborated with Hans Zimmer (a German) to create the rich score, and Taymor’s stunning costume design integrates traditional African ceremonial garb with clever puppetry—The Lion King succeeds with the kind of energy and imagination that’s extremely rare in entertainment of any genre or medium. It’s a bar-setting exemplar of what can be done with a Broadway musical, and it’s been going strong since its 1997 world premiere at Minneapolis’s Orpheum Theatre, where it’s currently playing a most welcome return engagement.

The 1994 animated film on which the musical is based has proven surprisingly sturdy—much more so than, say, Pocahontas (1995), which Disney animators were at the time much more enthusiastic about—but the stage adaptation improves on the film by deepening the story’s resonances with both African and European cultural traditions. On stage, there’s a clear anti-imperialist allegory that was buried in the film despite Jeremy Irons doing his louchest as the voice of villain Scar.

Not all of the new narrative and musical material added to expand the 87-minute movie into a stage epic is an improvement. Though the new instrumental and chorus material by Zimmer and Lebo M is wonderful, among the new songs (none were written by John or Rice) only “He Lives in You” is on the level of the songs heard in the film. One new scene, in which a delusional Scar tries creepily to seduce his nephew’s girlfriend Nala (“My, how you’ve grown!”), takes the show in a direction it really didn’t need to go.

It’s also true that there’s only one James Earl Jones (who voiced King Mufasa in the movie), but the touring cast are uniformly superb, making the roles their own with appropriately regal/craven miens—right down to the little b-girl baby elephant. One of the most extraordinary aspects of Taymor’s costume design is the way it amplifies rather than masks the actors’ human physicality: the lion masks worn by Dionne Randolph as Mufasa and J. Anthony Crane as Scar, for example, are perched atop the actors’ heads except when the lions are angry, when by movements of their shoulders the actors can cause the masks to slide down and extend. Among the show’s many striking visual tableaus is an eerie moment when Scar ascends a pile of bones in silhouette, Crane’s haughty mask extended on its spine-like support as though to illustrate the usurper’s fragile hubris.

From its first moment—the unforgettable gathering of a menagerie that inspired spontaneous applause among the opening night audience—to its last, The Lion King is a genuinely inspiring theatrical experience. If you’ve never seen it, go. If you have, you may well already have your ticket to go again.

- Jay Gabler

1:12pm  |   URL: http://tmblr.co/ZqCSNyEm4k0z
  
Filed under: The Lion King 
Liked posts on Tumblr: More liked posts »